Careful Settlement Planning and Documentation Essential
What is a Construction Defect?
Where a product defect or failure causes a construction defect and that defect causes personal injury or property damage, the product manufacturer will be liable in tort for the resulting harm.
A construction defect is any physical condition that reduces the value of a structure or endangers the health or safety of its occupants, that is a result of a flaw in design, materials, or workmanship, and that is not the result of normal aging or wear and tear.
Source: Justia
Examples of Construction Defects
Use of Structured Settlements in Construction Defect Settlements
An understanding of the nuances of construction defect cases, the exercise of careful settlement planning and documentation, is essential when contemplating the use of structured settlements in construction defect cases.
How Do Structured Settlement Annuity Issuers Report Payments with Construction Defect Structured Settlements?
At least one structured settlement annuity issuer that advertises construction defect cases as a potential for placement of its structured settlement annuities, will issue a Form 1099-Misc. for the full amount of payments it makes to plaintiffs/payees (without regard or provision to the basis of the plaintiff tax payer that may be reflected in settlement documents and the intentions of the settling parties).
This means that a plaintiff contemplating using a structured settlement annuity solution in such cases should retain the services of a CPA or tax counsel who is knowledgable about construction defects and accounting for loss-in-value of property, who is capable of properly addressing the potential mismatch in the reporting to the IRS by the annuity issuer and what is on the plaintiff’s tax return.
Consider what the IRS says about Loss-in-value of Property Settlements:
Source: IRS publication 4345 Publication 4345 (Rev. 9-2023) (irs.gov)
Consider What the IRS says about Intent of the Parties
Other References
FAQ What Are Some Accounting and Tax Issues Related to Construction Defect Settlements?
“Compensatory damages (amounts received for actual damages) – These amounts are generally excluded from tax as they are considered to be a return of capital, to the extent of the bases of the underlying assets. If there is any excess, the association will have taxable gain. However, if the excess funds can be used for other capital purposes the gain can be eliminated. Deductible capital expenses include the attorney fees and legal costs associated with the lawsuit. The tax cases on record state that the funds are set aside into a separate bank account and not commingled with operating funds.”
Source: Newman CPA Carlsbad CA, hoacpa.com
